Electronic commerce is the application of communication and
information sharing technologies among trading partners to the
pursuit of business objectives. In the real world of business
four distinct types of EC mingle and interact:
- Information access provides search and retrieve
capability for public domain and proprietary data
archives. The most common example of this type of EC is
the information service (e.g. Dialog, Nexus - Lexus, and
ABI Informs) that maintains a data base and charges for
access. Another example would be a case where a large
manufacturer communicates engineering change notices to
suppliers via dial-up access to a centralized database.
- Interpersonal communication services provide
methods by which parties with mutual interests can
exchange information, "discuss" ideas, and
improve their cooperation. Examples include customer and
supplier design groups jointly working out product
specifications, updated files being sent by a publisher
to a printer, and a purchasing agent using electronic
mail to negotiate an expediting schedule with a supplier.
- Shopping services allow people to seek and
purchase goods or services though electronic networks.
This form of EC for retail sales is what comes most
readily to peoples minds when they hear the term
"electronic commerce". But this genre of EC can
be extended in many other directions. As examples, it can
apply to the purchase of used industrial equipment,
commodities, or freight capacity.
- Virtual enterprises are business arrangements by
which enterprises separated by geography and core
expertise are able to engage in complex inter-related
business activities. One example would be true supply
chain integration, a situation in which planing and
forecast data are transmitted quickly and accurately
throughout a multi-tier supply chain. Another example
would be a situation in which non-competing suppliers to
a common customer use EC to allow the customer to do
"one stop shopping", with the assurance that no
matter how many suppliers are involved, a single phone
call will bring the right materials to the right location
at the right time.
Stage: Awareness Training | EC Questions
2. What makes electronic commerce different from other kinds
of commerce?
Electronic commerce is a combination of information
technology, telecommunications technology, and business process
to make it practical to do business in ways that could not
otherwise be done. To illustrate, lets draw on some
examples from the first question ("What is EC"?). In
each of these cases technology and business process must work
together if EC is to be successful.
Example of EC
|
Technology
|
Business Process
|
| Information
access Manufacturer provides
suppliers with access to data base on ECNs
|
Customer 1. Data base with reliable information.
2. Security fire-wall to control
outsiders access
Supplier
1. Computer with network access
capability
|
1. Customer
commits that data are current. 2.
Customer commits to inform supplier that a change has
been made.
3. Supplier agrees to use data base as
source of ECN information.
|
| Interpersonal
communication services Joint
customer - supplier design
|
1. CAD
systems which can understand each others files 2. Version control applications
|
1. Agreement
that joint design will take place 2.
Adoption of compatible design methods
3. Training of groups in collaborative
design
|
| Shopping
services Web to shop for
commodities
|
Seller 1. Web site capable of allowing on-line shopping
2. Web site capable of secure
transmission
Buyer
1. Web browsing capability
|
Seller 1. Ability to keep site current in an
environment of rapidly changing availability and price.
Buyer
1. Purchasing system that can commit to
a purchase without paper.
|
| Virtual
enterprise Integrated supply
chain
|
1. EDI 2. MRP
3. email (for exceptions)
|
1. Process
reengineering of order entry and purchasing systems to
allow integration of MRP and EDI. 2.
Staff assigned to resolving exceptions.
|
Stage: Awareness Training | EC Questions
Stage: Business Analysis
3. How can I take advantage of electronic commerce in my
business?
This question is as broad and difficult to answer as any
general question about making a business more competitive. How
for instance would you answer the familiar question: How can I
generate more business? Brainstorming and inspiration are useful
methods for answering this question, but the best solution will
come from combining these methods with a systematic approach. As
an example it would make sense to try to complete two matrices:
| With respect to your
customers |
Now
|
One
year from now
|
Five
years from now
|
| What is my competitive
advantage? |
|
|
|
| How much more business is
likely to be available from my current markets? |
|
|
|
| Are my products and services
appealing to markets I have not tapped? |
|
|
|
| What economic or
technological trends will affect the appeal of my
products or services? |
|
|
|
| Your capabilities with
respect to new products, services, or markets |
Presently
available
|
Easily
obtainable
|
Obtainable
only with great difficulty
|
| Manufacturing capacity |
|
|
|
| Technical capability |
|
|
|
| Sales and marketing
expertise |
|
|
|
| Capital |
|
|
|
The more unfamiliar the territory, the greater the importance
of system over inspiration. Thus to help answer the question
about using EC to benefit your business we offer a systematic
approach based on our virtual focus
group on trends in electronic commerce. The key to
discovering how EC can help your business is to answer the
following question:
How can my business benefit
from changes in how information
flows between me and my trading partners?
Answers to this question can be categorized along two
dimensions.
| |
Business Impact
|
| Product/Process |
Operations
|
Existing
customers
|
Developing
new markets
|
| Improve established process. |
|
|
|
| Enable a new process to be
established. |
|
|
|
| Allow new type of product or
service to come into existence. |
|
|
|
What kinds of business activities can be classified in this
way? Consider the following examples.
- X-12 based EDI is used to send traditional purchase
orders faster and with less expense. Without EDI purchase
orders would still flow, but not as quickly and at
greater expense.
- Your company uses the Web to search for commodity items
and used equipment that are listed in on-line catalogues.
This makes shopping easier and faster, but paper
catalogues are available and more than adequate for most
tasks.
- Engineering change notices, complete with graphics, are
sent via mail or over a network. As with purchase orders
the information would get be sent anyway, but is
transmitted more quickly (and perhaps in a more usable
form) through a network.
- Evaluated receipts settlement, a system that pays on the
bases of "evaluating" documents such as
purchase orders and shipping receipts, and thus does away
with a formal invoicing process.
- Large-scale just-in-time production systems.
- Concurrent engineering among your design teams and your
customers.
- Vendor-managed inventory based on point of sale data
capture.
- Groups of non-competing suppliers forming "one stop
shopping" systems for mutual customers.
By placing each of these examples into the matrix we end up
with:
| |
Primary Business Impact
|
Implementation
|
| Product/Process |
Operations
|
Existing customers
|
Developing new markets
|
ability to foresee benefits
|
risk of failure
|
potential payoff
|
| Improve
established process |
1 2 3
|
|
|
 |
low
|
low
|
| Enable a new
process to be established |
4 5 6
|
5 6
|
|
 |
moderate
|
moderate
|
| Allow new
type of product or service to come into existence |
|
|
7 8
|
 |
high
|
high
|
Added to the original table is a second section,
"Implementation." In its whole the table provides a way
to organize EC possibilities in terms of what product or process
they affect, what part of the business might be changed, and the
benefits and risks of implementation.
We recommend an approach that oscillates between the
systematic and the inspirational. As ideas are generated they can
be placed within the table, thus providing a sense of value and
risk. Working from the table, it becomes possible to decide on an
acceptable level of benefit and risk, and to then search your
business environment for possibilities that fit your comfort
level.
Stage: Business Analysis | EC Questions
Stage: Requirements Analysis